New Mel Gibson Film - Edge of Darkness (REVIEW)

ltstanfo

Member
Moderator
Joined
Apr 1, 2005
Messages
578
Reaction score
42
SUMMARY: Mel is back. If you enjoyed his past action / shoot-em ups, this film will return him to your good graces. While it is (IMO) darker than his usual fare, this could be the film that successfully returns him to the action genre. 8)

Gibson plays a Boston police detective whose daughter has come to town for a visit. When she is murdered on the front porch of his house (with him standing next to her) the initial thought is that he was the (revenge) target. Gibson quickly realizes that she was the target. Apparently his daughter worked at a "research facility" in Mass with some "interesting" ties to classified weapons research. Suddenly it seems as if the old cold war may be back. Lots of spooks, references to the military industrial complex with updates to reflect our current fear of terrorists with nukes. The rest of the film is Gibson learning the truth, who did it and getting even.

The Good: Lots of traditional "Mel" action. Think of his new character as a darker, much more somber (and less crazy) Martin Riggs. Like his previous character, this one has a military background and a long police (service) record. Think of this film as a cross between the "Lethal Weapon" series (without the humor) and the old Charlie Bronson "Death Wish" movies. He knows what he can and cannot do and more importantly what he can and cannot get away with (in the film). The bad guys quickly realize that they made a mistake in how they executed the killing of Gibson's daughter and try to cover it up by "dealing with" (as in trying to kill) Gibson.

The Bad: This really is a dark film, especially with regards to the topic of losing a child to a violent act right in front of the parent. While this isn't "bad" in my traditional way of reporting, I wasn't prepared for the scene and admit to flinching a bit when it occurred. The utter despair and emotional shattering of Gibson's character turning into seeking knowledge / getting revenge adds a layer to the plot and explains how Gibson's character descends into "darkness". Still, there are several scenes in this film which I would not take children to see.

The Ugly: None in my traditional sense. This film is what it is... a dark, violent, mystery and action filled shoot-em up. It has nothing to apologize for. You know very well what you are getting into from the previews.

Your mileage may vary.

Regards,
Ltstanfo
 
Nice review. I'll probably end up renting it one day.

To be honest, from what I knew of this movie I thought it was a Taken (with Liam Neeson) clone, but now I see it's a little different. Have you seen Taken? I really liked it.

Btw, did anyone see Rick Gervais' intro for Mel Gibson at the Golden Globe awards? If not, check it out (if you're impatient, skip to the 1:20 mark):
[youtube:yquaex3z]<object width="425" height="344"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/i6AxyQXVUJc&hl=en_US&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/i6AxyQXVUJc&hl=en_US&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="425" height="344"></embed></object>[/youtube:yquaex3z]
 
Glaucus said:
Nice review. I'll probably end up renting it one day.

To be honest, from what I knew of this movie I thought it was a Taken (with Liam Neeson) clone, but now I see it's a little different. Have you seen Taken? I really liked it.

Btw, did anyone see Rick Gervais' intro for Mel Gibson at the Golden Globe awards? If not, check it out (if you're impatient, skip to the 1:20 mark):

Yep, I saw "Taken" and enjoyed it as well. There really isn't anything in common between the two other than the father / daughter back story. I'll watch the youtube video at home this evening (blocked at work).

Regards,
Ltstanfo
 
I'm interested in seeing this. It was originally a BBC TV series from the early 80's and I get the impression this is quite different.

The original series is excellent so it has a lot to live up to as far as I'm concerned.
 
minator said:
I'm interested in seeing this. It was originally a BBC TV series from the early 80's and I get the impression this is quite different.

The original series is excellent so it has a lot to live up to as far as I'm concerned.

I've never seen the original series so I have nothing to compare the movie against. From what I have seen written by the "professional" critics, the general complaint seems to be that there is too much detail thrown into the two hour film. Also, while the story may be similar, the details have been adjusted for the times. Still, the new film has the involvement of the original (forget which) writer / director / producer (sorry, don't recall) so it cannot be all that bad (IMO).

Regards,
Ltstanfo
 
Back
Top